Independent guide — not a government agency. Applying for official programs is always free.How we make money  ·  Contact

Can You Go to Jail for Not Paying Acima? Missed Payments vs. Theft Laws

Can you go to jail for not paying Acima? Not simply for falling behind: missing lease payments is a civil money matter, and in the United States you cannot be jailed just because you owe a company money. The risk changes if you keep, hide, sell, or pawn leased property after the lease ends and the company has made a formal demand for it back, because some states treat that as a crime. This guide explains how an Acima lease works, where the civil and criminal lines fall, what Acima or a debt collector can legally do, and the safest ways out if you can no longer pay.

Updated November 18, 2026By the NRP Editorial Team10 min read

Quick answer

No, not for missed payments alone. The CFPB says a debt collector cannot have you arrested for an unpaid debt or threaten you with arrest. Acima can end your lease, ask for the item back, send the account to collections, or sue you in civil court. Jail becomes possible only in narrower cases: if you ignore a court order, or if you keep or sell the leased item in a state whose theft laws cover that conduct. Acima says you can return the item at any time to end the lease, which is usually the cleanest exit.

Key facts

  • Acima is a lease, not a loan: Acima buys the item and leases it to you until you finish paying or buy it early.
  • Missing payments: a civil issue; it can lead to collections or a lawsuit, not arrest.
  • Keeping or selling the item: can count as theft in some states once you get a written demand.
  • Court orders: ignoring a summons or judge's order can lead to a warrant, so always respond.
  • Way out: you can stop renewing and return the item to end the lease, per Acima.
Table of contents
  1. Can you go to jail for not paying Acima for missed payments?
  2. How an Acima lease differs from a loan
  3. Where criminal law can come in
  4. Civil and criminal risk side by side
  5. What Acima or a collector can legally do
  6. Court papers you should never ignore
  7. Options when you can no longer pay
  8. Spotting fake arrest threats
  9. Steps to take this week
  10. Related guides
  11. Frequently asked questions

Can you go to jail for not paying Acima for missed payments?

No. Falling behind on what you owe is not a crime. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau says a debt collector cannot have you arrested for not paying a debt, and threatening arrest breaks the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. What a company can do is sue you in civil court and try to collect through the court process.

Lease-to-own adds one wrinkle. With a loan, you own the item and owe money. With a lease, the company owns the item and you are paying to use it. So the question is not only "Do I owe money?" but also "Am I keeping something that belongs to someone else?" Most of the legal risk on this page comes from that second question.

The CFPB also notes one way any debt can lead to arrest: if a court orders you to appear or take some action and you ignore it, a judge may issue a warrant. That warrant is for disobeying the court, not for the debt itself.

How an Acima lease differs from a loan

On its About Leasing page, Acima explains that it does not lend you money. It buys the merchandise from the store and leases it to you. Some key points from Acima's own description:

  • No interest, but higher total cost. Lease payments are based on the item's value plus the cost of lease services, so owning through a lease costs more than the store's cash price.
  • Ownership comes at the end. You own the item after making all lease renewal payments, or sooner by using an early purchase option in your agreement.
  • You can end it. You can stop making renewal payments and return the item at any time to end the lease.
  • Customer service: (801) 297-1982, Monday through Friday 6 a.m. to 7 p.m. and Saturday 7 a.m. to 4 p.m. Mountain Time.

The Federal Trade Commission's guide to rent-to-own and lease-to-own plans warns that these deals can cost about twice the cash price. It also says that if you return the item or miss payments, you probably will not get back what you already paid. That is worth knowing before you decide whether to keep paying or give the item back.

For how lease-to-own compares with renting a home toward ownership, see our guide to rent-to-own homes.

Where criminal law can come in

Criminal charges are not about being broke. They are about intent and conduct with property you do not own. States handle this differently, and the details matter. Below are two examples from official statute text. They are not legal advice, and laws change, so check your own state.

Texas example

Texas Penal Code Section 31.04 (theft of service) covers some failures to return rented property after written notice demanding its return. But the same section carves out certain household lease-to-own agreements: as we read it, a personal, family, or household agreement that renews with each payment and lets you become the owner is excluded from the "written rental agreement" rules, and "service" does not include leasing that property. The section does still treat disposing of rent-to-own property in violation of the agreement, such as selling or pawning it, as diverting a service. It also lets a person rebut a failure-to-return presumption by showing they meant to return the property but could not.

In plain terms: in Texas, just being behind on an Acima-style lease is not theft of service, but selling or pawning the item can be treated as a crime.

Florida example

Florida Statutes Section 812.155 makes it a crime to knowingly abandon or refuse to return hired or leased personal property as agreed. The owner can send a written demand by certified mail or courier, and failing to return the property within 5 days after the demand is treated as evidence of refusal. Before a prosecution, the rental agreement must include a specific warning statement that the renter initialed. The penalty is a misdemeanor, or a third-degree felony if the property is worth $300 or more. The text we reviewed does not say how it applies to rental-purchase agreements, so a Florida lawyer is the right person to ask about a specific contract.

Other states

Many states have similar "failure to return rented property" laws, and most states also have rental-purchase laws that set rules for these contracts. Your state attorney general or consumer protection office can tell you which apply. You can find yours through USA.gov's state consumer office list.

Civil and criminal risk side by side

This table sums up how the most common situations are usually treated. Exact rules depend on your state and your contract.

What happensUsually civil or criminal?Likely result
You miss one or more paymentsCivilLate fees, calls, lease ends, possible collections
You return the item after stopping paymentsCivilLease ends; you usually lose what you paid; check for any amount still owed
Lease ends and you keep the item without payingCivil, with criminal risk in some states after a written demandDemand letter, collections, possible lawsuit
You sell, pawn, or give away the leased itemCan be criminal in many statesPossible theft or fraud charge
You ignore a court summons or orderCivil case, but contempt can followDefault judgment; possible warrant for not appearing
A collector says you will be arrestedIllegal threat by the collectorReport it to the CFPB and your state attorney general

What Acima or a collector can legally do

When an account falls behind, the company and any collector it hires have several legal tools:

  • Contact you by phone, mail, email, or text to ask for payment or the item's return.
  • End the lease under the terms of your agreement.
  • Send the account to a collection agency. Third-party collectors must follow the federal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act.
  • Sue you in civil court for the item or the money. If they win, state law decides what they can collect, such as wage garnishment where allowed.
  • Report the account to a credit or consumer reporting company, if the company reports.

What a collector cannot do matters just as much. Under 15 U.S.C. 1692e, a debt collector may not falsely say that not paying will lead to arrest or imprisonment, or threaten action it cannot legally take or does not intend to take. Collectors also cannot harass you or use abusive language. The CFPB's debt collection tools explain your rights and include sample letters.

A company also generally cannot break into your home to take back an item. If someone shows up, you do not have to let them in. If you want to return the item, arrange a pickup or drop-off in writing.

Court papers you should never ignore

If Acima or a collector sues, you will get court papers, often called a summons or a citation. This is the one piece of mail that can turn a money problem into a bigger one if you ignore it.

  • Read the deadline to answer. Missing it usually means the company wins by default.
  • File an answer or appear on the date listed, even if you agree you owe something.
  • Bring records: your lease, payment history, return receipts, and any letters.
  • Follow any order the judge gives, including orders to appear later for questions about your finances.

Free legal aid may be able to help. The Legal Services Corporation has a legal aid finder by ZIP code, and our guide to free legal aid for debt collection covers more options.

Options when you can no longer pay

You have more choices than it may seem. Here they are from simplest to most involved:

  1. Call Acima early. Ask what you owe, what happens if you return the item, and whether any payment date change is possible. Take notes with the date, time, and name of the person you spoke with.
  2. Return the item. Acima says you can end the lease at any time by stopping renewal payments and returning the merchandise. Get written confirmation of the return and ask whether any balance remains.
  3. Use an early purchase option if you are close to the end and it would cost less than continuing. Ask for the exact payoff in writing.
  4. Build a budget with a nonprofit credit counselor. The National Foundation for Credit Counseling lists member agencies that offer low-cost or free counseling.
  5. Get legal help if you are being sued or receive a criminal-sounding demand letter.

If several debts are piling up at once, our guide to consumer credit counseling services explains what a counselor can and cannot do.

Spotting fake arrest threats

Scammers use fear of jail to rush people into paying. Be cautious if a caller:

  • Says a warrant will be issued today unless you pay right now.
  • Claims to be from a sheriff's office, a court, or a "legal department" and asks for payment by gift card, wire, or a payment app.
  • Will not give a company name, mailing details, or the account number in writing.
  • Threatens to call your employer or family to shame you.

Hang up and call Acima using the number on your agreement or its website to check the account. Report false arrest threats to the CFPB complaint portal and scams to ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Steps to take this week

  1. Find your lease and read the sections on returns, early purchase, and default.
  2. Decide whether to keep paying, buy early, or return the item.
  3. Call Acima at (801) 297-1982 and get any agreement in writing.
  4. Never sell or pawn a leased item, even if you plan to pay later.
  5. Answer every court paper by its deadline and contact legal aid.
  6. Report illegal threats to the CFPB and your state attorney general.

Good to know: keep proof of everything, especially the date you returned an item and who received it. A return receipt is your best defense if anyone later claims you kept the property.

Frequently asked questions

Can you go to jail for not paying Acima?

Not for missed payments alone. Unpaid debt is a civil matter, and the CFPB says collectors cannot have you arrested or threaten arrest. Jail risk comes from ignoring a court order or from keeping, selling, or pawning leased property in a state whose theft laws cover it.

Can Acima press charges if I don't return the item?

A company can report suspected theft, but whether charges are possible depends on your state's law and your conduct. Some states treat refusing to return leased property after a written demand as a crime, while Texas excludes most household lease-to-own agreements from that rule but still covers selling or pawning the item.

Can I return my Acima item instead of paying?

Yes. Acima says you can stop making renewal payments and return the merchandise at any time to end the lease. You usually will not get back what you already paid, so ask in writing whether any balance remains.

Can Acima sue me?

Yes. Like any company, Acima or a collector can file a civil lawsuit for the item or money owed. Answer the court papers by the deadline, because ignoring them usually leads to a default judgment.

Is it legal for a collector to threaten me with jail?

No. Federal law bars debt collectors from falsely saying you will be arrested or jailed for not paying. Report the threat to the CFPB and your state attorney general.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Laws differ by state and change over time; for advice on your situation, talk with a licensed attorney or legal aid office. National Relief Program is an independent website and is not affiliated with Acima, Upbound, or any government agency.

Before you apply: program rules, amounts, and deadlines change. Always confirm details with the official agency or program administrator. Applying for government benefits is free.

National Relief Program is an independent guide, not a government agency. Spotted an error? Email support@nationalreliefprogram.org.